The Besht, the Gaon, and the Ban of 1772: The First Modern Schism

Print Article

The Besht, the Gaon, and the Ban of 1772: The First Modern Schism

Rabbi Jonathan Muskat, Modern Schisms lecture series, Lecture 1

Opening: A Door That Closed Twice

It is the winter of 1772. Two Chassidic leaders arrive in Vilna: R. Menachem Mendel of Vitebsk and a young scholar named R. Shneur Zalman of Liadi, who will later write the Tanya. They have come to meet the greatest Torah authority of the generation, the Vilna Gaon. They want to explain themselves, to answer the rumors, and to make peace.

They knock on the Gaon’s door. The door is closed to them. They come back. Again, the door is closed. The lay leaders of Vilna beg the Gaon to receive them. Instead, the Gaon leaves the city and does not return until the Chassidim have gone home.

A few months later, on Chol HaMoed Pesach, Vilna declares war on Chassidut. Writings are burned, leaders are arrested, and Chassidic minyanim are placed under cherem.

This is where our series begins, because this is the first great schism of modern Jewish history. Over the coming weeks, we will watch Orthodoxy confront the Haskalah, Reform, Zionism, Mordecai Kaplan, and its own internal divisions. Every one of those stories turns on one question, the title of the series: who speaks for Torah?

Today I want to use the story of the Besht and the Gaon, based on the work of the historian Immanuel Etkes, especially his book The Gaon of Vilna: The Man and His Image, to offer five chiddushim about how schisms work. These ideas will come back in every lecture that follows.

Let me start with the question underneath all of them. Jews have always disagreed. The Gemara is a book of disagreements. So why do most disagreements stay inside the beit midrash, while a few become two separate communities?

And a related question we will carry through the evening: was the conflict between Chassidim and Mitnagdim a schism at all, or only a near schism? Chassidim today are not a separate denomination. By the end, I hope to show why it came so close, and why it stopped short.

Chiddush 1: Ideas Don’t Create Schisms. Classification Does.

The Besht: a new kind of authority

We usually say the Baal Shem Tov founded Chassidut. Etkes says that needs a careful qualification. The Besht died in 1760. Chassidut became a movement only in the 1760s and 1770s, after his death. He built no institution and never imagined one.

What he did create was a new model of religious leadership. We see it in his famous letter to his brother-in-law (his wife’s brother), R. Gershon of Kitov, written around 1752 and known as the Iggeret HaKodesh. The Besht describes how, on Rosh Hashanah, his soul ascended through the heavenly worlds until he reached the palace of the Mashiach. He asked the Mashiach, “When will the master come?” The answer, in translation:

“By this you will know: when your teaching becomes known and revealed in the world, and your wellsprings spread outward (vayafutzu ma’ayanotecha chutzah) — what I have taught you and you have grasped — and they, too, will be able to perform yichudim and aliyot as you do. Then all the forces of impurity will be destroyed, and it will be a time of favor and salvation.”

The phrase yafutzu ma’ayanotecha chutzah, “let your wellsprings spread outward,” comes from Mishlei 5:16.

Those two words, yichudim and aliyot, need a little explanation. Yichudim, “unifications,” are meditations from the Kabbalah of the Arizal. A person concentrates on combinations of the Divine names, with specific kavanot, to bring unity to the upper worlds, between Kudsha Brich Hu and the Shechinah, and to repair souls. Aliyot are aliyot haneshamah, ascents of the soul: the soul leaves the body and rises through the heavenly worlds. That is exactly what the Besht is describing in this letter. It is how he got to the Mashiach’s palace in the first place.

Until then, these were practices of a tiny elite of kabbalists. The Mashiach says redemption will come when they spread. Later in the letter, the Besht writes that in heaven he learned three segulot, charms, and three holy names, which were easy to learn and explain. He hoped his colleagues could use them to reach his level, but he was not given permission to reveal them.

Notice two things. First, the Besht’s authority does not come from a rabbinic position or from being the greatest lamdan. It comes from his soul, his prayer, his access to the upper worlds, and his ability to help people, physically and spiritually. Etkes calls him baal shem, public leader, and mystic. Second, the message points outward. Scholars argue about how far: Gershom Scholem reads it as opening mystical experience to every Jew, while Etkes reads “others” more narrowly, as the Besht’s own circle. Either way, spiritual power now flows through a charismatic master and his disciples, not through the rabbinic hierarchy of learning. That is the seed of what will later be called the tzaddik.

Here is the point. For all its novelty, this did not yet make a schism. The Besht lived and died inside the Jewish community. His circle davened in the same towns and kept the same halacha.

There was criticism, and it was sharp. R. Yechezkel Landau, the Noda BiYehuda, Chief Rabbi of Prague, was asked about the new Chassidic custom of reciting the kabbalistic formula l’shem yichud Kudsha Brich Hu u’Shechintei, “for the sake of the unification of the Holy One, blessed be He, and His Shechinah,” before performing mitzvot. He answered that the practice should be abolished. He calls it a sickness of the generation, describing people who abandon the study of the two Talmuds, the Bavli and the Yerushalmi, and turn to esoteric matters, each one claiming that the gates of heaven have opened for him. He closes with a pasuk from Hoshea: “For the ways of Hashem are straight; the righteous walk in them, v’chassidim yikashlu bam, and the chassidim stumble in them.” (Noda BiYehuda, Mahadura Kamma, Yoreh De’ah 93)

Now look at those last three words. The pasuk in Hoshea (14:10) actually says u’fosh’im yikashlu bam: “and sinners stumble in them.” He replaced “sinners” with “chassidim.”

There is a well-known story about that line. When the teshuvot were later printed, someone changed the word back to posh’im. The Noda BiYehuda supposedly shrugged: “I turned posh’im into chassidim, and they turned chassidim into posh’im.”

It’s a good joke, but notice what it is: words. Harsh words, but no cherem, no expulsion, no ban on minyanim.

The Gaon: from “different” to “heretic”

Twelve years after the Besht’s death, everything changed. Why?

Historians have offered three answers. Jacob Katz says it was about ideas: tradition defending itself against a dangerous new way of serving God. Ben-Sasson says it was about power: communal leaders protecting their control. Dubnow says it was trauma: twenty years earlier the Frankist heresy had shaken Polish Jewry, so leaders were primed to see a new sect as a threat.

Etkes does not reject any of these. But he says none of them is enough. His answer is one person: the Vilna Gaon.

He makes a striking observation. The Chassidim did not reject halacha. Aside from complaints about davening late, no one accused them of violating mitzvot. Any local rabbi could have declared heretics those who openly broke the Torah. But to declare a halachically observant group heretical required someone with unique authority: the greatest scholar of the age, a kabbalist, and a living symbol of Torah and yirat Shamayim.

And so, Etkes writes, the idea that Chassidut was a severe deviation “was not self-evident.” It became true for Lithuanian Jewry because the Gaon said so.

Consider the letter Vilna sent to the community of Brisk in 1772, signed by the Gaon and the Vilna beit din and later printed in the anti-Chassidic collection Zemir Aritzim. The letter describes the new sect, calling its members not chassidim, pious ones, but chashudim, suspects, a one-letter change. Its first charge is not a theological doctrine. It is that they gather in separate groups, form their own minyanim, and change the nusach of tefillah. The letter calls on the community of Brisk to pursue them, to break their power, and to scatter them, so that “not two heretics remain together.”

Hold on to that last line. We will come back to it.

That is the first chiddush. A disagreement becomes a schism when an authority reclassifies the other side, from “wrong” to “outside.” The ideas were the same the day before the ruling and the day after it. What changed was the category.

Etkes even has a test for this. Before the Gaon intervened, and after he died, opposition to Chassidut was mostly words and polemics. Only while he was alive and leading did it become cherem, arrests, and burning books.

Chiddush 2: A Schism Is Sealed by Refusing to Meet

Let’s go back to the closed door. Why wouldn’t the Gaon simply meet them?

Our source is R. Shneur Zalman’s own account, in a letter he wrote twenty-five years later, in 1797, to his Chassidim in Vilna. He opens by saying that if peace were possible, there is no greater mitzvah, and that he and his colleagues tried everything to achieve it. Then he describes what happened when they came to Vilna: they went to the Gaon’s home to debate with him and remove his complaints against them, v’sagar hadelet ba’adenu pa’amayim, “and he closed the door on us twice.” When the leading men of the city pressed him hard to meet them (ka’asher hechelu lehaftzir bo me’od), arguing that if he could defeat them in debate there would be peace in Israel, he evaded them by leaving town, and he stayed away until the Chassidim had left the city.

Why? In another letter, R. Shneur Zalman explains. By the time they knocked, the Gaon had already decided. He had heard testimony from people he trusted that the Chassidim mocked talmidei chachamim and did strange things in davening, even turning cartwheels and standing on their heads. Then an intermediary brought him a distorted version of a Chassidic interpretation of the Zohar. The Gaon saw heresy. As far as he was concerned, the trial was over.

Notice who wanted the meeting. Not only the Chassidim. As we just saw, R. Shneur Zalman says the leading men of Vilna, probably the parnasim, the communal lay leaders, were the ones pressing the Gaon to receive them. Etkes suggests they hoped that if the two sides talked, the Gaon could impose his authority and contain the matter. The person who refused was the one with the most authority.

That is the second chiddush. Disagreement survives conversation. Schism requires its absence. As long as people are arguing with each other, they are still in one community; a machloket is a relationship. The moment one side says “there is nothing to discuss,” the other side is no longer an opponent but an outsider.

R. Shneur Zalman says this plainly when his own Chassidim in Vilna later ask for a debate or arbitration. It is pointless, he says. Even if arbitrators ruled in our favor, no one in Lithuania would dare to set aside the Gaon’s opinion. When authority refuses to listen, there is no forum left in which to disagree.

And the door stayed closed. In 1781, a second, harsher cherem forbade lodging Chassidim, eating their shechita, doing business with them, marrying them, or even helping to bury them. In 1796, the Chassidim spread a rumor that the Gaon had changed his mind. His answer was a new letter, even sharper than before, calling on every believing Jew to pursue them. When Chassidim in Minsk questioned whether his signature was authentic, he sent an even harsher condemnation. Every attempt to reopen the door closed it more firmly.

We will see this again. In Hungary, in Germany, in America, the question is always partly: who is willing to sit in the same room?

Chiddush 3: How You Respond Decides Whether You Stay Inside

Now look at the other side. How did the Chassidim respond to being excommunicated?

After the ban spread, the Chassidic leaders gathered at the home of their teacher, the Maggid of Mezeritch, the Besht’s successor. They had options: print counter-attacks, answer insult with insult, perhaps issue bans of their own. The Maggid chose none of them. Their only response would be tefillah.

Twenty-five years later, R. Shneur Zalman looks back and says that restraint is why Chassidut grew to “thousands and scores of thousands.” The louder the attacks, the more people came to see for themselves, and found that the accusations were false.

Then there is something even more surprising. How do the Chassidim talk about the Gaon, the man responsible for their suffering? They defend him. He was not malicious, they say. He was misled by false witnesses and a distorted report. He acted on testimony he had every reason to trust.

Why defend your persecutor? Etkes gives two reasons. The practical one: attacking the Gaon’s honor would only widen the rift. The deeper one: if the greatest Torah scholar of the generation called you a heretic, you carry that stain forever, unless he was misinformed. By saying “the Gaon erred in good faith,” the Chassidim kept the Gaon and kept their own legitimacy at the same time.

Later Chassidic writers developed three ways of telling the story. Some admitted the persecution and said it saved Chassidut from going astray. Some said both sides learned from each other. And some simply left the persecution out.

The third chiddush: the side that is pushed out decides, by its response, whether the break becomes permanent. The Chassidim refused to accept their own exclusion. They did not form a counter-church or declare the Mitnagdim illegitimate. They insisted they were inside, and they honored the authorities of the community that expelled them. That is a major reason this schism eventually became a division within Orthodoxy, not a division of the Jewish people.

There is a second part to this, which is that Chassidut corrected itself. Every revolution tends to produce its own internal counter-revolution. R. Shneur Zalman wrote the Tanya, but he also wrote the Shulchan Aruch HaRav, a full halachic code. A first-rate talmid chacham at the head of a Chassidic movement was the best possible answer to the charge that Chassidim scorned Torah.

And listen to what R. Shneur Zalman’s grandson, R. Menachem Mendel Schneersohn, the third Rebbe of Chabad, known as the Tzemach Tzedek, reportedly told a Mitnagdic rav. Chassidim, he said, do not appreciate the great kindness the Gaon did for us by opposing us. Had it not been for the Gaon’s opposition, the fire of Kabbalah might have burned up the Talmud. In other words, the excitement of the mystical could have pushed aside the hard work of Gemara and halacha. The Gaon’s opposition forced Chassidut to prove its commitment to learning, and so it never let go of the Talmud. A Chabad Rebbe thanking the Gaon for the cherem: that is how a schism is turned back into a family argument.

Compare that, in a few weeks, with the Reform movement, which defined itself against the tradition, and you will see the difference.

Chiddush 4: Schisms End in Coexistence, Not Reunion

How did it end? Not with a peace treaty. Two things happened. The Gaon passed away on Sukkot of 1797. And in 1804 the Russian government recognized the Chassidim’s right to their own minyanim. The very thing the cherem of 1772 had banned was now protected by law.

But the decisive change came from inside the Mitnagdic camp, from the Gaon’s greatest student, R. Chaim of Volozhin. R. Chaim still thought the Chassidim were wrong. He worried most about what Chassidut was doing to the status of Torah study, as young men left the beit midrash. But he did not think they were heretics, and he believed their motives were pure.

So he changed the weapons. Instead of cherem, he wrote Nefesh HaChaim, a systematic argument for the supremacy of Torah learning. Instead of burning books, he built a yeshiva in Volozhin. The struggle moved from persecution to persuasion.

Notice he never names the Chassidim. In Nefesh HaChaim, he writes that he has seen people who spend so long preparing themselves to daven that the zman of Mincha has passed. When you say to one of them, “Let’s daven Mincha,” he answers, “Let’s check whether the stars have come out yet.” A sharp critique. But listen to how he ends: v’Hashem yislach lahem, “may Hashem forgive them.”

Elsewhere in the same work, he describes people who spend all their days studying books of yirah and mussar, rather than Tanach, Gemara, and halacha. Again he writes: Hashem yislach lahem, ki kavanatam l’Shem Shamayim, “may Hashem forgive them, for their intention is for the sake of Heaven,” but, he adds, this is not the way.

Compare that with his rebbe’s word in the 1772 letter: heretics.

One might ask: is purity of motive really what makes someone not a heretic? Isn’t heresy about what a person believes or does, not why? That is a fair question. But I think R. Chaim’s shift was not really about the definition of heresy. It was a shift in categories: from “they are outside” back to “they are wrong.” It undid the Gaon’s reclassification without conceding the argument.

Now look at a Gemara in Yevamot (13b–14a). The Torah says lo titgodedu (Devarim 14:1). In its plain meaning, the pasuk forbids gashing oneself in mourning, but the Gemara reads it as a play on words: lo ta’asu agudot agudot, “do not form separate factions.” Rava defines exactly what that means:

“When we said lo titgodedu, it refers to a case like two batei din in one city, one ruling like Beit Shammai and one ruling like Beit Hillel. But two batei din in two different cities, there is no problem.”

I find that a remarkable definition of a schism. It is not about how strongly people disagree. It is institutional: two authorities, side by side, in the same space. That is exactly what Vilna feared in 1772: separate Chassidic minyanim in the same town. And that is exactly what the Russian government made permanent in 1804.

Now go back to the Vilna letter of 1772. Its stated goal was that the Chassidim be scattered “so that not two heretics remain together.” The Gaon’s camp understood Rava’s point perfectly: the real danger was not an idea, but a separate group.

The fourth chiddush: schisms rarely end with one side returning to the other. They end when parallel institutions learn to live side by side, each recognizing the other as wrong but legitimate. Chassidim and Mitnagdim never reunited. Each kept its own shuls, rebbes, and yeshivot. But they stopped calling each other heretics, and that is the difference between a schism and a division within one community.

One more factor helped. By the early 1800s, both camps faced a much larger challenge: the Haskalah. A common threat has a way of making yesterday’s enemies into allies.

Chiddush 5: A Schism Is a Process, Not an Event

We like founding moments. The Besht founded Chassidut; the Gaon declared war in 1772. But Etkes keeps pointing us away from moments and toward processes.

The Besht did not create a movement; his students did, decades later, by spreading his reputation and his way of avodah. The Gaon did not create the Mitnagdic camp alone; it took communal leaders, a network of disciples, and finally R. Chaim and Volozhin to give it a lasting institutional form. And the schism did not happen on one day in 1772. It took shape over thirty years: a ruling, a closed door, a cherem, a restrained response, a death, a government statute, and a yeshiva.

So the fifth chiddush: charisma begins a schism, but institutions make it permanent. A schism exists when disagreement has hardened into separate structures of authority: separate shuls, separate leaders, separate schools. And because it is a process, there are points along the way where it can still be slowed, contained, or redirected.

Closing: “Sofah Lehitkayem”

Let me end with the Mishnah in Avot (5:17):

“Every machloket that is for the sake of Heaven, sofah lehitkayem, will endure; and one that is not for the sake of Heaven will not endure. Which is a machloket for the sake of Heaven? The machloket of Hillel and Shammai. And which is not for the sake of Heaven? The machloket of Korach and all his followers.”

We usually read this as a promise about the people: both sides will survive. But I would suggest a sharper reading in light of today’s story. It is the machloket itself that endures. A dispute for the sake of Heaven is never resolved, and it is not supposed to be. Beit Shammai and Beit Hillel argued for generations, and still, the Gemara says, they did not refrain from marrying into each other’s families (Yevamot 14b).

The tragedy of 1772 was not that Chassidim and Mitnagdim disagreed. That disagreement was for the sake of Heaven, and it endures to this day. The tragedy was the attempt to end it by expulsion, to turn a machloket into a cherem. And the healing came, not when the disagreement ended, but when both sides accepted that it would continue.

Today, Chassidim and Litvaks daven in the same shuls, learn the same Gemara, and still argue. Etkes points out that echoes remain, all the way to the confrontation between the Lubavitcher Rebbe and Rav Shach. But no one calls the other side heretics.

Over the coming weeks we will ask, again and again, the questions we asked today. Who classified whom? Did anyone refuse to meet? How did the excluded side respond? Did the result become two batei din in one city? And did the schism end in reunion, coexistence, or permanent separation?

Next time: the Haskalah, when for the first time the challenge to rabbinic authority came not from a new kind of piety, but from a new kind of knowledge.